Punishment and Prisons
Power and the Carceral State
- Joe Sim - Liverpool John Moore's University, UK
Joe Sim has long occupied a key position in British and European criminology. This book is a genuinely important addition to the literature; it is controversial and will stimulate debate. Punishment and Prisons shows that critical criminology is alive, that it has a voice and that it needs to be read. - Peter Young, Professor of Criminology, University of Hull
'A satisfyingly uncompromising critique that has no fear of coming to clear conclusions and provides little succour to those satisfied with short term change in the current system. Sim provides the kind of concise, articulate and powerful critique of apparent criminological realities, which is necessary to motivate genuine reform and can help to ensure that practitioners and others do not forget the big picture.' - Probation Journal
Joe Sim offers a rich and persuasive analysis of imprisonment, providing a wealth of political and policy detail. He makes his reader confront the cruelties of imprisonment as well as its ineffectiveness in reducing crime, and it would surely be impossible to read this book without feeling profound disquiet about the deployment of the power to punish in contemporary Britain. Punishment and Prisons has a breadth and depth of scholarship, arguing powerfully for a more critical criminology and an abolitionist stance towards imprisonment. I urge all those interested in penal policy - whether as students, teachers, researchers, reformers, politicians or penal professionals - to read this important and disturbing book. - Professor Barbara Hudson, Centre for Criminology and Criminal Justice Studies, University of Central Lancashire
With prisons overflowing and penal policy the topic of hot debate, Punishment and Prisons: Power and the Carceral State presents a lively and accessible discussion of possible solutions to the current crisis, by one of the foremost scholars in the field.
Joe Sim traces the development of penal strategy over the past three decades, through a critical analysis of the relationship between penal policy and state power. Exploring the contested histories of punishment that are prominent in criminology, and its development in penal policy, the book analyses four key dimensions of modern penal trends:
" continuity and discontinuity in penal policy and practice
" reform and rehabilitation
" contesting penal power
Articulate, innovative and theoretically informed, Punishment and Prisons: Power and the Carceral State offers a critical overview of contemporary penal politics that will prove a compelling addition to the criminological library.
The book is written for not only for students and academics but also for those involved in the debates on penal policy - including prison reform groups, politicians and the media. It offers a series of suggestions for alleviating the current crisis, setting out a policy agenda for transforming the role and place of the prison in the criminal justice system.
Overall, the book is an impressive and provocative achievement. A brief summary cannot do justice to the wealth of detail and subtlety of argument contained in the pages. Among the many important themes explored in the book perhaps the most significant is the enduring presence of the prison within the political landscape of the last three decades. Indeed, one of the major strengths of the book is the way each of the substantive chapters has a nuanced grasp of the ideological struggles surrounding crime and punishment within both Conservative and New Labour administrations.
A fantastic text that offers not only a supplementary overview to the prison system, but offers the level of critical discussion needed for third year students. I found this text very enjoyable to read and recommend it to any penologist.
A must for students of penal institutions
A leading authoritive text on the the current strategy of punishment of the poor and the powerless. Inciting discussion, debate and critique. A must read for any undergraduate seeking to evaluate the impact of discrimination in state responses to crime, control and regulation.
An excellent book which I read from cover to cover in a day and a half. Beautifully written and scholarly in style it offers an incisive critical analysis of the development of penal policy in Britain since the mid-1970s. This is well worth recommending to students who may not have a full understanding of the political contexts in which penal policies have been developed. As such it will assist them to offer more scope to their essay and exam answers on the subject of punishment.
The content was easy to read and comprehensive.
An excellent text that addresses many important and complex issues and debates within penal policy.
An interesting read which poses some key areas of thought for undergradute students studying this subject.
I will be putting this on a recommended reading list for one module
The author presents key developments and discussions in penal practice in a logical and systematic manner, with an emphasis on the chronological developments in the use of custody. The politicisation of imprisonment that is articulated in this text are pertinent to current reforms in penal thought, and therefore this serves as an essential source for those studying contemporary criminal justice practices. An excellent text for undergraduate and post graduate learners as well as scholars
An excellent text which covers its topic in an informative and critically challenging manner.